Theatre in Review: The King's Critique (Pershing Square Signature Center) Late in the second act of The King's Critique, songwriters Eric Holmes and Nat Zegree show us what they can do. The show's plot -- which we'll have to get into, but let's not rush things -- unfolds at a theatre festival in a musical-comedy version of early Renaissance England. The number, which amounts to a play-within-the-play, is titled "The Gem of Arcanum Vitae." It's the story of a young woman who, following the death of her beloved father, roams the world looking for the item in the song's title, aka the secret of life. After a seemingly endless search, she discovers it in the fellowship of others who love to tell stories. It's a nifty piece with a lovely, soaring melody, and, like "Meadowlark" from The Baker's Wife, I can imagine cabaret singers taking it up en masse. It makes a classy calling card for a pair of artists currently better known for their television work. And with Taylor Iman Jones to put it over, it's a delight. But what is it doing in The King's Critique? It is weirdly out of place in this ragtag romp that wants to be Once Upon a Mattress crossed with Something Rotten!, with maybe a touch of A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Forum. It's a gag-a-minute entertainment, and nobody is too picky about quality. This is clear in the opening number, which confuses "thespians" with "lesbians." (I think I first heard one in high school.) Later, a character defines diplomacy as "negotiating peace between kingdoms. Helping people come together." Of course, somebody replies, "I love coming together!" Then there's this choice bit: King: "She's clearly a witch." Henchman: "You can say that again." King: "She's clearly a witch." In keeping with the story's time frame, we also get innumerable jokes about the plague, which are about as funny as...you know. On occasions like this, the customary defense is to say The King's Critique is merely lighthearted froth, along the lines of, say, Shucked and one should simply lie back and enjoy the vaudeville of it all. Fair enough, but that's no excuse for the authors' rooting around in the bargain bin for the cheapest possible laughs. (I'll draw a veil over the many fart jokes.) When anyone can guess the punchline before the actor delivers it, your show is in trouble. Anyway, we're in the realm of "His Majesty King Benjamin McMerrick FitzWebber O'Rudin deBrantley Von-Nepobaby the sixty-ninth," who, for no reason other than the plot demands it, presides over a theatre festival. Although everyone lives in terror of his disapproval, he rarely shows up, except this time, which is unfortunate because the gifted writer/performer Josephine (daughter of "Richard the Prior") intends to make her stage debut. This is a scandalous idea in a world where women aren't allowed to act; as someone warns, "But you can't take the stage 'cause you got a 'gina!" Soon, Josephine, her sidekick Sebastian, and Cora, a several-hundred-years-old sorceress, hatch a plot to break King Benjamin's theatrical hegemony. The idea is to put on a total stinker that he will rave about, thus exposing his incompetence in true Emperor's New Clothes fashion. But if you've seen The Producers, you know where this is headed: The play, a five-hour-plus epic consisting of nothing but a chair placed onstage, is a sensation, cueing a flood of copycat efforts, including Lamp in the Piazza (with "Dame Angela Lampsbury" and Waiting for Bureau. All of Josephine's actor friends are put out of work, Cora is dispatched to "a fiery pit of doom," and it looks like everyone will be exiled to The Middle West, from whence no one returns. Surprisingly, this hoke-fest is directed with considerable verve by Catie Davis, aided by choreographer Nancy Renee Braun, on the theory that if everyone acts like they're in a hit, it will be so. God knows, they try: Sky Lakota-Lynch, a Tony nominee for The Outsiders, shoulders more than his share of embarrassments. He also gets the lion's share of the scrotum jokes. (Dressing for a gala party, King Benjamin says, "I pride myself on my balls." "Indeed," replies Sebastian. "Word far and wide was that you have the finest balls in the land." This goes on for several minutes.) Lakota-Lynch also spends much of the second act dressed as a seal, although he and Jones pair up nicely when romance comes calling. As the King, Justin Collette is good enough to make one wonder what he might do with decent material. Donna Lynne Champlin, who never disappoints, camps it up authoritatively, applying her best grand manner as Cora. Matthew Patrick Quinn has a fine slow burn as Horrace, the king's right-hand man, who has secret pervert tendencies. As a temptress winsomely named Isabella VonGlorysnatch, Gabi Carrubba has projection problems in her big number, but she vamps the male cast members with dedication. Thank heaven for Jones, who strides through this nonsense with a warm presence, a fine voice, and a sense of purpose. Also helping to keep things watchable is the production design, beginning with Paul Tate dePoo III's set design, featuring a traverse stage complete with drawbridge; the cast also ingeniously rigs up a mini-theatre stage for the festival scenes and deploys a series of pillars to suggest the underworld of a sewer. Cory Pattak's protean lighting design conjures an abundance of looks using various colors and angles; he even slips into concert-touring mode for one number. Emily Rebholz's costumes are amusing riffs on standard double-and-hose ideas: King Benjamin is hoodwinked into wearing a ballgown that would get a nice hand at the Met Costume Gala and Isabella parades around in a pannier miniskirt. Jessica Paz's sound design, aside from one or two numbers, is surprisingly good, especially given the theatre's configuration. By the finale, with everyone singing about the glory of theatre ("Share your light, share your love/Let your passion rise above/Don't give in to your fear"), you may have a few critiques to offer, too. Still, there's that "Arcanum Vitae" song, and a few decent offerings, which leave one wondering: Holmes and Zegree have other shows in the works, which have been acclaimed in out-of-town engagements; clearly, they are capable of more. Maybe this is their Musical Husbands, the audience-baiting claptrap that Franklin and Charley write in Merrily We Roll Along, strictly to get a Broadway foothold. I'm sticking to this theory until somebody disproves it. --David Barbour 
|